Ok, so you have read the final book, did it tie up all the loose ends or do you have questions left unanswered?
According to MuggleNet, here is a list of some of the loose ends that were "out there" before the 7th book came out, did these all get answered for you?
- Will Hogwarts reopen? And, if so, will Harry, Ron, and Hermione attend for their seventh year?
- Answered in Book 7 - Is Snape good or evil? Where do his loyalties lie?
- Answered in Book 7 - What is the significance of Harry having his mother's eyes?
- Unanswered - What caused Dumbledore trust Snape so much?
- Answered in Book 7 - Why was Voldemort going to allow Lily to live after he killed James at Godric's Hollow?
- Unanswered - Who is R.A.B.?
- Answered in Book 7 - Are Dumbledore and Sirius actually dead? Update: JKR confirmed in New York that Dumbledore is in fact dead - but we still don't know about Sirius!
- Answered in Book 7 - Where are the remaining Horcruxes? And furthermore, was Dumbledore right about what the remaining Horcruxes are? If he wasn't, what are they?
- Answered in Book 7 - Who will lead the Order now that Dumbledore is dead?
- Unnswered? - Is Bill Weasley a full werewolf?
- Unanswered - Did Voldemort go to Godric's Hollow alone the night he tried to kill Harry? If so, how do people know the events of that night?
- Unanswered - Will the two-way mirror that Sirius gave to Harry come up again?
- Answered in Book 7 - Is the relationship between Ginny and Harry really over? Will they get back together in the end?
- Answered in Book 7 - What was the "gleam of triumph" in Dumbledore's eyes at the end of Goblet of Fire?
- Answered in Book 7 - Is there more behind Voldemort wanting the DADA teaching position so badly, or is it just because he simply wanted the job?
- Answered in Book 7 - How will Peter Pettigrew repay his life debt to Harry?
- Answered in Book 7 - What lies beyond the veil in the Department of Mysteries?
- Unanswered - If Dumbledore and Petunia were in contact before Harry was taken to Privet Drive, then what were they discussing in their letters?
- Answered in Book 7 - Who was "that awful boy" who Petunia referred to in OOTP? Was it James, or was it somebody else?
- Answered in Book 7 - Will Ron and Hermione's relationship finally come to be, or will something happen to prevent it?
- Answered in Book 7 - What were Lily and James' occupations?
- Unanswered - Will Dumbledore's portrait be of any use to Harry?
- Answered in Book 7 - What will Percy do now that the Ministry has been proven wrong and Dumbledore is dead? Will he return to his family?
- Answered in Book 7 - Where did Fawkes go at the end of Half-Blood Prince?
- Unanswered - What did Dumbledore see or experience after he drank the potion in the cave in HBP?
- Answered in Book 7 - How exactly did the Potters and the Longbottoms "thrice defy Voldemort"?
- unanswered specifically - Assuming Hogwarts will open in Book 7, who will be the DADA teacher?
- Answered in Book 7 - Again, if Hogwarts remains open in Book 7, who will teach Transfiguration if Professor McGonagall becomes headmistress? And will Slughorn remain to teach Potions for a second year, even though he said he would only be there for one?
- Answered in Book 7 - Will the terms of the Prophecy be fulfilled? If so, will Harry kill Voldemort, or will Voldemort kill Harry?
- Answered in Book 7 - On her website, JKR stated that "there IS a significant - even crucial - answer" to the following question: How and why did Dumbledore have James' invisibility cloak? What is the significance of this?
- Answered in Book 7 - What happened to Ollivander? And since there was no sign of a struggle when he disappeared, whose side is he on? And what about Florean Fortescue - are their disappearances linked?
- Answered in Book 7 - Will Ron and Harry pass their Apparation tests?
- unanswered - What about Dumbledore's family? (JKR said in her interview with MuggleNet/TLC that Dumbledore's family would be a "profitable line of inquiry.")
- Answered in Book 7 - If Voldemort lost his body at Godric's Hollow, then who retrieved his wand?
- unanswered - What's behind the locked door in the Department of Mysteries?
- unanswered, still a mystery - Why did Regulus choose to leave the Death Eaters?
- Answered in Book 7 - Will we learn any more about Dumbledore's brother Aberforth? Will he have an important role to play in the book?
- Answered in Book 7 - What happened to Dumbledore's wand after his death?
- Answered in Book 7 - What did Dumbledore actually see in the Mirror of Erised in the first book?
- Answered in Book 7 - Who will reinstate the protective barriers around Hogwarts that Dumbledore removed so he and Harry could fly to the tower? Not just anybody could have taken them down or Hogwarts would be constantly attacked. Is Dumbledore the only one who knew how to perform those charms?
- unanswered - How did Dumbledore know the details of Lord Voldemort's murder of Lily - how LV offered to spare her life and how the charm that protects Harry was formed - if no one else was there to witness it? Was Dumbledore actually there to witness it?
- unanswered - What were Dumbledore and Snape arguing about that Hagrid overheard at the edge of the forest in HBP? Was it about spying on Draco, or was it something else?
- Answered in Book 7 - What will become of the Malfoy family? Specifically, will Draco remain loyal to Voldemort, or will he change his mind and fight for the other side?
- Answered in Book 7 - Where did Snape and Draco go at the end of the sixth book?
- Answered in Book 7 - In Chamber of Secrets, Lockhart says that he transformed a werewolf back into a man using the "immensely complex Homorphus Charm." Now we know that Lockhart didn't actually do this, but he did steal the story from another wizard. So, is there a way to cure Lupin?
- unanswered - Will the giants and goblins take a firmer position about the war? Will they ever choose a side?
- Answered in Book 7 - Are we going to see SPEW again? Will the house-elves' rights be improved by the end of the series? And what will become of all of the house-elves that we know so far in the series?
- answered in part - Do we know the whole story behind Dumbledore's hand injury in HBP?
- Answered in Book 7 - What are the twelve uses of dragon's blood that Dumbledore discovered? Will these discoveries be important to the story in any way?
- unanswered - Who helped R.A.B. retrieve the locket from the cave? (Dumbledore made it clear that two people were needed to get past Voldemort's enchantments.) And where is the locket now?
- Answered in Book 7 - What significance is the fact that Mundungus Fletcher has been stealing things from Grimmauld Place going to have to the plot of the next book? Did he take the locket from Grimmauld Place, and if so, who did he sell it to? Will Mundungus be playing an important part in the next book?
- Answered in Book 7 - JKR said that someone will manage magic very late in life in Book 7: who will it be? Filch, perhaps?
- Answered in Book 7 - Did Dumbledore have a will or anything equivalent to a will?
- Answered in Book 7 - Did Hagrid have to be able to see thestrals in order to train them? If so, whose death did Hagrid witness?
- unanswered - When Harry was taking Occlumency lessons from Snape in OOTP, he put more than one memory into the pensieve. What other memories did he want to hide from Harry?
- Answered in Book 7 - Is there any significant reason that wizards come of age at age 17?
- Unanswered - When Snape is about to kill Dumbledore, Dumbledore says, "Severus... Please..." Was Dumbledore asking Snape to kill him or was he asking for mercy?
- Answered in Book 7 - What was the potion that Dumbledore had to drink in the cave?
- Unanswered - How did Dumbledore become such an "extraordinary magic user, even at a young age" (a quote from an OWL examiner in OOTP)? Was it just study and hard work, or is there something different about him?
- Unanswered - If Hogwarts is opened again in the seventh book, who will be Head Boy and Head Girl?
- unanswered - Will Luna have a prominent role in Book 7? Will she live through the war?
- Answered in Book 7 - Is there a connection between Godric's Hollow and Godric Gryffindor?
- Answered in Book 7 - Do we know the full reason that Voldemort decided to try to kill Harry instead of Neville?
- Unanswered - How did Hagrid retrieve Harry from the ruins of his parents' house if he was not told the location by the secret-keeper?
- Unanswered - Now that Dumbledore is dead, who is the secret-keeper of the Order of the Phoenix? Is the spell broken?
- Answered in Book 7 - Is there more to the curtain that Sirius fell through in Order of the Phoenix
- unnswered - Where did the Potter family's wealth come from?
- unanswered - What truly determines whether or not someone becomes a ghost? Is there more to it than what Nearly Headless Nick said there was?
- Answered in Book 7 - What is Grawp's role going to be in Book 7? Will he even have a role?
- Answered in Book 7
So what do you think, did you have any other questions, new questions created by Book 7, or other oddities you wanted to talk about?
JKR did a great job of tying up the most import loose ends in the book, and I loved the book. Here were a few questions that I didn't quite understand:
1. We learned in the beginning of Book 7, Deathly Hallows, that Voldemort used Creature to drink the liqud in the basin for him to hide the locket, but at the end of the 7th book, Voldemort was able to get to the bottom of the basin wiithout help, did it not refill itself like it did after Regulus drank the liquid?
2. It seemed odd that Nevil was able to pull the sword of griffendor out of the sorting hat after the Goblin got the sword, if that was the case, Harry really didn't need to worry about loosing it.
Posted by: Abe | July 26, 2007 at 04:23 PM
I think that the question about why Lord Voldemort was going to let Lily live was answered. He was going to let her live because Snape asked him to. Begged him to.
Posted by: Amanda | April 04, 2008 at 05:03 PM
I think that the question about why Lord Voldemort was going to let Lily live was answered. He was going to let her live because Snape asked him to. Begged him to.
Posted by: Amanda | April 04, 2008 at 05:03 PM
the question about hagrid retrieving harry without being the secret keeper was answered in the 7th book.
"The Fidelius charm must have died with James and Lily." harry says this when he and hermione go to Godrics Hollow right before meeting Bathilda.
And about the question concerning lily and james' jobs. didnt Dumbledore say that they were Aurors? i am not completly sure about this i only think.
Posted by: Anne Boleyn | June 16, 2008 at 04:42 PM
I can't believe no one realized that after Bill's wedding, Crookshanks is never again mentioned, except as an incredulous remark by Hermione that they have more important things to think about.B
Posted by: Bucky Nineteen Tooth | July 19, 2009 at 12:21 AM
As usual, I am working backward. I just read the "Deathly Hallows" and have not read any of the previous Harry Potter books. But I have seen most of the movies. I really enjoyed Book 7... but do you longtime fans believe it's possible to really get the true "magic" of the series this way? Do you think it would be a good idea (or anticlimactic) for me to go back and read "Sorcerer's Stone" et al?
Posted by: jayalay | September 09, 2009 at 09:00 PM
Jay,
I think you should go back and read from the beginning. Also if you don't want to read them all, try one on Audio. The audio presentations are masterpieces in and of themselves. Jim Dale is simply amazing.
Adam
Posted by: Adam | September 09, 2009 at 09:11 PM